"Of all tyrannies a tyranny exercised for the good of its victim may be the most oppressive. It may be better to live under robber barons than under omnipotent moral busybodies. The robber baron's cruelty may sometimes sleep, his cupidity may at some point be satiated, but those who torment us for our own good will torment us without end for they do so with the approval of their own conscience.
- C.S. Lewis. "

Understanding
The Numbers

Studies

Smoking Bans
And Businesses

Odds and Ends

   

Smoking Ban Links
Archive 1

 

This page is obsolete. It's only here for archival purposes. All the information on this page (and much, much more) is available here.

- - -

The list of articles about business severely affected about bans became so long we had to break it up into several pages. This page, archive one, contains the oldest links. You'll find additional links in archive two, Archive Three and Archive Four. The most up to date links on this page.

You'll find quite a few dead and expired links here. Many news organizations only make articles available for a limited time. You may be able to visit their home page and order the article.

Fargo smoking ban debate is about business survival (Expired Link. Source: In-forum.com)

A Lakewood, Wash., casino (with restaurant and bar) has laid off 15 employees since the Tacoma-Pierce County Board of Health’s new smoking regulations went into effect in earnest Feb. 26. Managers say they will lay off 40 to 50 more if the business slump, which they blame on the ban, continues.

“My tips have gone down from $70 or $80 a day to less than $20,” Tracy Willows said at the end of her shift, when she is shaking her head at the 20 bucks -- if she’s lucky -- in her pocket and wondering if her pay will be enough to fill her gas tank, much less put food on the table or buy gym uniforms for her two kids.

We are starving.

...he recounted a conversation he had had with a woman who supports the ban gleefully, who quipped obliviously that “my hair doesn’t stink, my clothes don’t stink, and there’s so much room at the bar.”

Restaurant smoking ban puffing along a year later (Expired Link. Source: Kansas City Star)

Edna Hardwick, owner of Montgomery's, said she's never served liquor and doesn't think she should have to just to keep her 40-year-old eatery from closing. But most of her customers have flocked to other diners. "A year ago this place would have been full," Hardwick said, indicating the small lunch crowd. "Now we're operating in the red."

Law has bar owners fuming

(Expired Link)

The consequences, according to Toni Clifford, a bartender at Ace's, are already apparent. On a normal weekday afternoon, she used to take in at least $30 in tips. Yesterday, she was hoping for $5.

Defiant pub flouts new Irish smoking ban

The city centre pub in Galway, western Ireland, has seen its business drop by 60 percent since March when smoking in workplaces became illegal.

Parties snuffed out (Expired Link)

“Where’s all the non-smokers that said 'we can’t go to the bar because there’s smoking,'” she added.

“We stop the smoking — where are they?”

Montgomery County restaurant, bar owners say smoking ban has hurt them (Expired Link)

"I've probably lost $50,000 since October," Levy said. "Everyone is going to VFWs, lodges and country clubs," where smoking is permitted.

Sign paper, light up. Smoking ban defied at bar (Expired Link. Newsday)

Naylon said when smokers returned to Jimmy Mac's in April, its bar business increased by $25,000 from the previous month.

Where there's no smoke ...(Expired Link. Hear ld Tribune)

Sales from the late-night crowd at Bogey's between 10 p.m. and midnight are down about 25 percent, primarily because of lower liquor sales, he said.

Smoking ban, 1 year later (Expired Link. Palm Beach Post)

"It has almost put me out of business. We are down about 45 percent for each month," Zook said. "Our food sales were 48 percent of our business. Now they are down to 10 percent. A lot of people who had drinks with lunch or dinner are not coming in now."

...The Ale House's food sales have rebounded and are up 6 percent over a year ago, but for the first five months of 2004 alcoholic beverages sales were down $2 million compared with January through May of 2003, Reid said.

The other outcome of the smoking ban

The Web - a small tavern in Ogdensburg - will close its doors Saturday.

Owners Janet and Anthony Doerr say the smoking ban destroyed their business. Since it went into affect, the Doerrs says business has gone down hill.

Village Inn seeks relief from ban (Expired Link. Pioneer Press)

He estimated that sales are off by as much as 37 percent in daytime business...

"Since I last appeared at a board meeting in July of 2003," he said, "the Village Inn has been forced to lay off six employees and my payroll has gone from $47,000 to $25,000 per month," he said.

Closed For Good (Expired Link. New York Post)

Most of the tickets — prompted by complaints from nightlife-hating neighbors — were for excessive noise inside or for "disorderly sidewalk" when smokers loitered outside. "Now 70 people are out of jobs," Ferraro said.

Irish Pub Owners Call for Smoking Ban to Be Eased as Sales Drop

Suppliers of drinks to Irish pubs have posted a decline in sales of between 15 percent and 25 percent...

Lexington smoking ban blamed for decline in bingo revenues (Expired Link. Kentucky Heard-Leader)

Lafayette's bingo also has been affected. On the third Saturday in May last year, Lafayette had 139 players at its bingo session and made $2,219. This year, it had 104 players and raised $65.

Restaurants file to halt, repeal smoking ban (Expired Link. The Northwestern.com)

Ratchman said business is up at Ratch and Deb’s. But he said his business’s gain is another’s loss. He said customers fleeing smoke-free establishments have flocked to his restaurant since the ban went into effect on April 19.

“I like to be busy, but I don’t like to take stuff from other people,” Ratchman said.

How to light up local nightlife again (Expired Link. Newsday.com)

I talk with other service providers (food, alcohol, cleaning supplies, even state-sponsored "Quick Draw" gambling). When it comes to bars, restaurants and other businesses they serve, they all have the same story: Many have closed.

Bar, tavern groups tout smoking ban study

The study also found that businesses which supply and service bars have lost 2,650 jobs, $50 million in earnings and $71.5 million in gross state product.

Group: Smoking ban hurts business (Expired Link: Newsday.com)

A study released Tuesday by the New York Nightlife Association and the Empire State Restaurant and Tavern Association said the ban that went into effect in July has also led to $28.5 million in lost wages and $37 million in lost gross state product. Affiliated businesses lost another 650 jobs and $56 million in wages and production, the study by Ridgewood Economic Associates said.

Fayetteville Restaurant Owners Criticize Smoking Ban

Casa Taco is one restaurant that recently closed its doors. The owner told 40/29's Melissa Kelly that the smoking ban snuffed out his sales.

"Sales dropped off dramatically," said Alex Hunt. "We lost our late-night business ... a lot of people come in after the bars close."

Along with Hunt, the owners of the Ozark Brewing Co. and Café Santa Fe said the smoking ban was a factor in their decisions to close.

Other restaurants, such as Hoffbrau, are taking a major hit.

"Our restaurant business is good, but we've lost 50 percent of our liquor sales," said manager Scott Mayes.

Smoking ban hurts profits, bars say (Expired Link. Maine Sunday Telegram)

The ban, he said, is costing him $70,000 a year in gross profit. "I'm making up some in food sales, but it will take me five years to get back to the profit margin I was making two years ago."

That loss is trickling down to his employees, he said. "It affects whether I can provide insurance and benefits to key employees," he said.

Smoke-free move threatens diner (Expired Link. Ontario Chronicle Journal)

Angelo Bazzoni said that after his Highway 17 eatery banned the weed on Jan. 1, business fell off by more than half and has yet to recover.

Bar smoking ban: Air cleaner, business down (Expired Link. Maine Today)

They say customers disappeared when the law went into effect in January. The president of the Maine Restaurant Association says business is down by 30 percent at some establishments, especially those near New Hampshire, where tavern air retains its smoky haze.

"Business is off big-time," Dick Grotton said. "The law continues to be a source of extreme irritation."

Businesses Look For Ways Around Smoking Ban

Allen Gilbert owns Friends and Company. "We've lost a lot of our happy hour crowd. Since the smoking ban has gone into effect, we're down almost 30-percent."

The restaurant has experienced the lowest revenue in the last 19 months.

Smoking ban hitting trade, claim vintners

Figures from the Dublin trade clearly show that on average, pub revenues have been hit by between 12% and 15%

Smoke-free fans never showed up

Lisa Sorochan, an owner of the late, lamented Bacchus, says it was hurt badly when the city's smoking bylaw reduced business by about 50 per cent. The Bacchus opened in 2000. In its first two years, it regularly would close to its 275-person indoors capacity, Sorochan says. As business dwindled, you'd be lucky to find 60 patrons on hand. One estimate of the loss at the Bacchus is $100,000.

Taps for Union Colony Brewery

Owner Larry Oyler said Greeley's smoking ban, enacted in December, was the crushing blow to the business that has slumped through a down economy since 2001.

Business Shuts Doors Due To Smoking Ban

Owners of Nicholson's Cigar Bar say it didn't make sense to operate a smoke-less cigar bar.

Tougher smoking ban waiver

The bar has been a family business for more than 30 years, and they've never had a problem until now. Business dropped drastically after the smoking ban went into effect last year. Kolor has even had to dip into her retirement money.

Pipe Dreams (Expired Link. New York Post)

"Sandee Wright, the co-owner of Whiskey Ward on Essex Street, said she was battling a 30 to 40 percent drop in sales.

"I've had to lay three people off, starting with my doorman - my husband does it for free now," she said."

Smoking ban a cancer on business, bar owners say (Expired Link. Norwich Bulletin)

"Our afternoon business is gone. We've lost quite a bit."

"Bar owners claim they are losing as much as 60 percent of their business as smokers flock to establishments where they can light up."

"Lora Wilson, owner of Mugsy's Cafe in Oakdale, said she is losing $150 a day and is cutting back on shifts because she can't afford to pay her staff of four."

Ban blamed for $2.9-million cut in funding (Expired Link. Canadia.com)

Communities across Manitoba are going to feel more economic fallout from smoking bans.

The bans are being blamed for a $2.9 million cut to urban development initiatives in Winnipeg this year, such as housing and tourism projects.

Jobs will go up in smoke with statewide smoking ban (Expired Link. Norwich Bulletin)

"For example, the Grand Central Casino in Lakewood reports that since the ban took effect in February, liquor sales are down 42 percent and food sales have dropped 25 percent. Fifteen employees have been laid off and another 40 to 50 jobs are in jeopardy."

"As one beleaguered casino employee asked the health department officials, "how many people have to lose their cars and their jobs and their homes before you see that trying to protect my health is endangering my livelihood?"

Bar and restaurant owners plan to fight smoking ban (Expired Link. Norwich Bulletin)

Bar owners claim they are losing as much as 60 percent of their business as smokers flock to establishments where they can light up.

Bar owners hope to fight smoking ban (Expired Link. Norwich Bulletin)

Since the beginning of April when the state ban on smoking in bars took effect, the bartender at the Brown Derby on Route 32 said her income has dropped by more than half.

Smoking ban hurts track (Expired Link. Philadelphia Inquirer)

William Rickman Jr., president of Delaware Park, said the ban resulted in a $36 million loss in gross revenues last year and about $72 million throughout the state.

Owner Closes {Tavern}, Blames Smoking Ban

After 10 years in business, a neighborhood bar is closing its doors. The owner blames the state's smoking ban.

Smoking ban burns businesses

"This casino has laid off 15 employees since the Tacoma-Pierce County Board of Health's new smoking regulations went into effect in earnest Feb. 26. And managers say they will lay off 40 to 50 more if the business slump, which they blame on the ban, continues.

"My tips have gone down from $70 or $80 a day to less than $20," Willows said."

Counting the cost of New York's smoking ban

"They said the ban would be good for business and for employees, yet my business is down and three good staff are out of work and unable to find another job. One big irony is that most of my staff are smokers, and now they’re being protected from second-hand smoke."

The {The New York Nightlife Association} claims that 76% of 300 members surveyed about the ban said business had fallen by an average 30%.

Smoking bans could snuff out small bars, eateries

In New York City, where legislators are considering amendments to the smoking ban, 76 percent of bars and nightclubs experienced a 30 percent decline in business.

Banning the ban on smoking (Expired Link. Newsday)

It's worse at Tony's Sports Bar & Restaurant in Queens Village. "It killed our business," said owner Tony Narain. Within the past year, alcohol and beer sales have declined 70 percent, he said. "I'm losing money right now."

All puffed up over cig law

Bar owners and their patrons said the past 12 months have been an economic disaster: Bar stools and cash registers are empty, clubs break the law just to survive and smokers are pushed into the street to puff.

"New York City has gone from the city that never sleeps to Sleepy Hollow," said Tom Carrube, manager of Sharkey's Sports Bar and Grill on Staten Island. He estimates that revenue has plummeted 60% as regulars stay home or head to nearby New Jersey for a beer and a smoke.

Oswego Co. grants four smoking ban waivers

Restaurants Blame Smoking Ban For Closings

Members of the restaurant association said their alcohol sales have dropped since the ban by 20 percent to 25 percent.

Up in smoke?

Businesses with smoking-ban waivers waiting for rebound

Smoking ban may be hurting lotto sales

Joe Mancino owns the Fulton Ale House. He says that since the smoking ban took effect, his business is down 25%. While that may not sound like anything new, Mancino says the money he collects for the state's Quick Draw game is down as well.

DBJ Confidential - Dallas Ban Costs Hotels a Million Dollars in Lost Revenue

At the Hyatt Regency Dallas, general manager Steve Vissotzky says the Hyatt has lost more than $750,000 in '03 sales because the ban includes hotel meeting rooms. Cigar Aficionado magazine canceled a March event there, and Philip Morris nixed a meeting in August. Over at the Fairmont Hotel, meanwhile, GM Frank Naboulsi says ban-related cancellations total $250,000 so far

Smoking ban may snuff out lodge (Expired Link)

A band was playing Friday Oct. 10, one day after the ban went into effect, and the no-smoking signs were posted. "[Customers] walked in and walked out," Radice remembered. "Everyone left and went into town and the remaining six non-smokers left because they were bored."

"The first weekend the band played for me and Steve," said bar manager Chrissy Seltzer of Poolesville. "It was horrible."

Smoking ban hurts local business

Since the state's smoking ban took affect in July, there hasn't been a lot of laughs at Viva Debris Comedy and Magic Club. Business is down, way down.

"We have lost about 30% of our business which includes 30% of our staff," said owner Joe Delion.

Smoking bylaw clears out curling club bar

The president of Inuvik's Curling Club predicts it will lose $40,000 by the end of the year, and says the town's smoking by-law is to blame. Don Craik told town council Monday night that members are no longer spending money in the club's bar, putting the club's future in jeopardy.

Bylaw put me out of business, restaurant owner says

Pierce County Casinos Cry Foul Over Smoking Ban

Tioga Health Board nixes all smoking ban waivers (Expired Link. Ithica Journal)
Veterinarians are among those deciding the fate of bar and restaurant owners.

Hotel, Club Owner Turning To Internet To Net A Sale

Another NYC bar closes

I just closed my bar in lower Manhattan about two weeks ago. I felt bad laying off seven workers. Most of them had been with me during the five years Swan's was open. None of them had ever complained about secondhand smoke. Taverns are dropping like flies, but not from smoking or cancer."

Smoking bylaw hurting business, says hotel owner

Anti-Smoker Activists resist any attempt at wavers.

Niagara County Bars experience 17% loss due to ban.

Bars and restaurants in Niagara County estimate a 17 per cent loss of business is on the low end since the smoking ban went into effect. I'm told business at some establishments is down by 50 per cent and more.

No Smoking? No Customers

Tony Almeida, co-owner of Eightball VIP Sports Cafe in Chatham, said the bylaw has had a “drastic impact.

“I would say sales have been impacted to the tune of 40 per cent or more,” he said.

Mattydale bar closes after smoking ban

It may have looked like a party, but patrons were saying their good-byes to Cam Nel. The bar closed its doors Sunday after more than 50 years of serving the Mattydale community.

To smoke or not to smoke?

Zoi Christanis' said her business at Christanis Bar and Grill is down 40 percent.

Mills Calls for Repeal of Smoking Ban

NY smoking ban leads to job losses

According to new research one in 10 jobs in the New York pub and bar sector have been lost since the city introduced its ban on smoking in the workplace in March.

War on Smokers

Another list of links to business that have suffered because of smoking bans. Also reports of smokers being harassed and attacked by anti-smokers.

10,000 new workers scam

The Nicotine Nannies lie again.

Effects of ban in NYC

A few miles away, in downtown Manhattan, the waitresses at McCann's restaurant pub have given up waiting for a lunchtime diner. "No one's coming to eat here from work," says the bartender, Luke Sullivan. "There's a deli downstairs. They get their sandwiches from there and eat them outside, where they can have a smoke as well. Waitresses pay their rent with tips. Now they're not getting any."

Bingo Players Decry Smoking Ban

Bingo halls expect to lose at least 20 to 30 percent of their business once the ban takes effect.

California Bar Owners Vow to Continue to Fight California Smoking Ban (1998)

"'It's running people out of here,' said (Terry) Schaner, a bartender for 13 years at the Antlers (in Pinole.) 'It's probably cost me about $150, $200 a week in tips,' he said -- about half of his income."

For Bart's, ban on smoking is a killer

Less than a year after the city of Louisville enacted a no-smoking ordinance in all restaurants, Bart's, a fixture in the town for nearly three decades, shut its doors last week.

It had in recent months become a deserted shell of its former self. The bar, like many in Louisville restaurants these days, stood empty all day.

NYC busts shop owner for ashtray

A business owner who left an ashtray sitting out in his shop has been fined $6,000 by New York City's health inspector, who was enforcing the city's tough, new anti-smoking law.

On the ticket, health inspectors M. Dundas and S. Holloway reported: "One (1) ashtray with cigarette butt, and ashes, was seen on the counter of the establishment."

The ashtray was there, he said, because a customer came in the store with a cigarette. Rather than make her go back outside, Arno let her snuff it out in the ashtray.

Bingo Halls Want NYS To "Butt" Out

Workers say profits are down 50 percent this month. On a Tuesday night in September 2002 about 143 people played at Bingo World in Greece. Only 79 showed up on the same night this year.

Bingo revenues go up in smoke

“Some of the charities are hurting, significantly,” he said, adding, “we're seeing a decrease in charity dollars in the vicinity of $35,000 to $40,000 a month.”

Anti-Smoker movement attacking smokers in their homes

Promising to spark a debate over government's role in people's personal lives, the bill would allow neighbor to sue neighbor to rid apartment and condominium complexes of wafting tobacco smoke.

Smoking ban has business fuming

Sales at Montgomery County bars and restaurants have slipped by as much as 50 percent since a smoking ban went into effect less than three weeks ago, owners said yesterday.

Smoking Ban Puts Restaurant Profits Up In Smoke

In Haverhill, the bar banter has moved outside. Three months ago, the city banned smoking in most restaurants. The ashtrays may be gone, but so are the customers.

"I would say we lost 30 to 40 percent of our business right off top since March 1, and it happened that day," restaurant owner Mike Difeo said.

It was a similar story at Benny's farther north on Route 125.

"It's a struggle. I've lost $49,000 as of today, and I can see I lost my main base of customers because of non-smoking. I am losing help. My people are not making money. I went from 58 employees to 44 employees," restaurant owner Ben Brienza said.

Smoking hearing snuffed

I went from making a very good weekly paycheck to making minimum wage,'' Miller said. I'm now making less than a McDonald's employee.''

Cafe business up in smoke

Sales were down $3,000 in July 2002 compared to July 2001. Hardest hit were on Friday nights and Sunday mornings.

This may be the most frightening article on these pages

Physicians for a Smoke Free Canada advocate taking kids from smoking parents. (PDF file)

One way of protecting childern from harm is ensuring they are not exposed to second hand smoke. . .Sometimes, where are unable or unwilling to provide a safe and secure environment for their children, the courts can provide provincial governments as temporary guardians. . .When the government is in the position of parent, the responsibility of protecting children from second hand smoke is transferred from the natural parents to the government.

The government meets it's parental responsibilities provincial child protection systems, using foster homes as the main tool to watch over children in their care.

Some opinion pieces:

Passive aggressive

Musician Joe Jackson debates with a nicotine nanny MD, and makes him look like a fool.

Give Them Liberty - To Smoke And Eat

I've never smoked, but I hate this law. It's government overstepping its powers, and it can be cruel.

Rage, rage against the dying of the lighters

This has become a religion, you know, a crusade with all the shuddering hallmarks of zealotry crossed with pedantry — the theocracy of the Tobacco Taliban, the Rapture of the Righteous, the Passion of the Pious.

Tyranny by bylaw blows, so do smoking Stalinists (Expired Link)

Bar owners who complain about an unequal playing field — that they would lose customers to establishments that permit smoking or that shelled out for soon-to-become-obsolete separately ventilated spaces — actually reinforce, with their whingeing, the inherent stupidity of the bylaw. What they're admitting is that, given a choice, smokers will vote to smoke, with their feet. (I don't mean they'll actually smoke with their feet, although I've seen people do this and it's a neat trick.)

Mike's run may go up in smoke

New York does not want or need Nurse Ratched as mayor.

Cruelty to Smokers

Smoking Ban Proposal is an Attack on Property Rights

Flying Fists and Cancer Sticks

I was sitting outside Terminal 5 at LAX, smoking a cigarette, waiting for a friend, when a mother and her young daughter walked by. While passing me, both, as if with Pavlovian reflexes, broke into Tony-worthy faux-coughing fits. The two, it seemed, were waging a passive-aggressive war on smoking. It was as if they'd earlier made a pact to chide every smoker they encountered.

Health Czarina Rules from on High

Thank You for Not Drinking . . . In the Bar

Wanted: A Few Good Lawyers

Smokonomics

 

If you'd like to see an article added to this list, please send us the link.



 

© 2000 - 2012 Dave Hitt

Permission is granted to use this information, in whole or in part, however you like.
Attribution and Links are appreciated but not required.

Home | Contact Us


Like this? Find more at DaveHitt.Com